Valentine’s Pre-orders

At the Co-op, it’s our mission to make your holidays stress-free and effortless. Elevate your Valentine's Day with our pre-order delights! From savory surf and turf to scratch made sweet treats, indulge in a romantic culinary experience. Secure your favorites today and celebrate love with us!

Pre-orders open Wednesday, January 28 – Wednesday, February 11 🌹

📅Pick-up dates: February 13 + 14 at both stores

Pre-order from Elmwood
Pre-order from Hertel

Surf and Turf Meal Kit for Two*

$49.99

(2) Creekstone Filet Mignon – 6oz

Hand cut in house from the beef tenderloin, the most tender cut of beef possible. Black angus, humanely raised and treated with care. Melt in your mouth tender.

(2) Lobster Tail - 4 to 5oz

Cold water lobster tail; rich tender meat. Sweet buttery flavor. Simple to prepare, elegant on the plate. Wild caught in Canada.

*$49.99 Surf and Turf (Uncooked) Meal Kit deal is only available for pre-order online, not available in-store

Desserts to Delight Your Valentine

Raspberry Cheesecake for Two

Handmade Assorted Chocolate Truffles

Hand Dipped Chocolate Covered Strawberries


Dozen Roses $29.99

Fresh roses only available in-store for the holiday.


Pre-order Instructions

Click here to place your Elmwood Valentine’s Day pre-order

Click here to place your Hertel Valentine’s Day pre-order

1. Begin Shopping!

2. Do not log-in or click “guest”

3. Complete order & payment

Need help?
Pre-order customer service is available at (716) 886-1036, Monday – Friday, 9 AM – 5 PM

Cookie & Cream Cheesecake Slices

Chocolate Peanut Butter Rice Krispy Heart

Flourless Chocolate Cake